Close Menu
Healthtost
  • News
  • Mental Health
  • Men’s Health
  • Women’s Health
  • Skin Care
  • Sexual Health
  • Pregnancy
  • Nutrition
  • Fitness
What's Hot

So easy Diy Eye Contouring Gel-The final anti-aging recipe!

July 27, 2025

Erectile dysfunction in young men: causes and solutions

July 27, 2025

Revealing the origin of autism, depression, Parkinson’s in the fetal brain

July 26, 2025
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Disclaimer
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Healthtost
SUBSCRIBE
  • News

    Revealing the origin of autism, depression, Parkinson’s in the fetal brain

    July 26, 2025

    The new study identifies the critical gene for treatment

    July 26, 2025

    Heavy smoking is linked to atrophy in Alzheimer’s brain areas

    July 25, 2025

    Creatine can enhance neuroprotection through energy routes

    July 25, 2025

    Here’s the ACA Premium hikes

    July 24, 2025
  • Mental Health

    How mothers who support mothers can help cover the lack of healthcare and other barriers to care

    July 22, 2025

    Do you have to trust a AI mental health application? -Poic details, privacy risks and 7 -point security checklist

    July 19, 2025

    3 ways Canadians can take control of their finances in a time of economic uncertainty

    July 18, 2025

    Exercise can significantly benefit the mental health of adolescents – here they say the items

    July 13, 2025

    Awareness Month for Mental Health 2025: Turn awareness into action

    July 9, 2025
  • Men’s Health

    Prostate cancer and erectile dysfunction

    July 24, 2025

    30 minutes of full body workout to burn fat and enhance strength

    July 23, 2025

    Erythritol changes brain function and may increase the risk of stroke

    July 21, 2025

    Cardio vs. Training Power: Which is better for shrinking medium -age fat?

    July 21, 2025

    New peak health technologies for all men over 40

    July 20, 2025
  • Women’s Health

    What are we watching: Medicaid matters more than ever

    July 25, 2025

    How do you treat the vagina? Effective, non-relief-Vuvatech, non-surgical options

    July 24, 2025

    Probiotics of Multiple Executives for Bowel, Skin and Energy Support

    July 23, 2025

    Power beyond the game: Vicky Fleetwood

    July 22, 2025

    Can you get magnesium with multivitamins and other vitamins?

    July 21, 2025
  • Skin Care

    So easy Diy Eye Contouring Gel-The final anti-aging recipe!

    July 27, 2025

    What is a light moisturizing and why do you need a

    July 26, 2025

    Glazed Cherry Lips + Must-Have Glosses

    July 26, 2025

    Bicarb, magnesium and search for perfect Pit formula

    July 24, 2025

    All thermal flx | About aesthetics

    July 24, 2025
  • Sexual Health

    Erectile dysfunction in young men: causes and solutions

    July 27, 2025

    Trans Fighters are fighting to get discrimination in basic martial arts

    July 26, 2025

    3 Sti you can catch even if you are using a condom

    July 25, 2025

    How to try HIV in Australia: Free, Fast and Private

    July 21, 2025

    Do orgasms change over time?

    July 21, 2025
  • Pregnancy

    A spiritual approach to maternity and connection

    July 26, 2025

    67 Perfect Baby Book Inscriptions

    July 24, 2025

    Restore your week with these Storms-Rose Stork

    July 22, 2025

    Why French baby names tend to modern mothers

    July 21, 2025

    Last minute baby gifts that still join each mom

    July 17, 2025
  • Nutrition

    45 Vegetable Summer Picnic Recipes

    July 23, 2025

    Episode 007: The Power of Critical Thinking: Why Success requires Brave Options with Sean Croxton

    July 22, 2025

    Do you need a glucose screen if you don’t have diabetes?

    July 22, 2025

    Do you have a dessert? Here is 5 natural GLP-1 foods for dessert

    July 21, 2025

    Grammie + Pea Camp 2025 • Kath eats

    July 20, 2025
  • Fitness

    Master the Seated Ab Pike Compression: The ultimate deep core and Flexor Hip exercise for serious lifters

    July 25, 2025

    6 Best Hiit Training Shoes of 2025, per trainers

    July 25, 2025

    Jacksonville Hiking Trails: Fresh Air & Fun for all

    July 23, 2025

    My healthy stack of sleep: what I use for deep, restorative rest

    July 23, 2025

    New Dumbbell training for beginners (plus my favorite exercises 💪)

    July 22, 2025
Healthtost
Home»Sexual Health»Gender-affirming care and the dignity of risk
Sexual Health

Gender-affirming care and the dignity of risk

healthtostBy healthtostDecember 11, 2024No Comments7 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Reddit WhatsApp Email
Gender Affirming Care And The Dignity Of Risk
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest WhatsApp Email

Last week, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in the case United States v. Skrmettiwhich asks whether the state of Tennessee should be allowed to enforce a ban on care for gender-affirming youth.

Everywhere argumentsseveral themes emerged in the questions coming from the Court’s conservative justices. One of these was the supposed danger of gender-affirming care.

“If treatment is blocked, some children will suffer because they cannot access treatment. If the treatment is allowed … some children will suffer receiving the treatment and later wish they hadn’t and want out,” Judge Brett Kavanaugh said. “And so there are risks on both sides here … it’s a difficult crisis as a matter of policy.”

American Civil Liberties Union attorney Chase Strangio — who happens to be the first openly transgender person to argue a case before the Supreme Court — appeared on behalf of the original plaintiffs in the case, several families and a doctor. She pointed out that much of the evidence about grief and transition cited to justify bans on gender-affirming care is old and often comes from studies of very young children. Controversial to Skrmetti are treatments such as puberty blockers and hormones, which do not apply to children who have not reached puberty.

“Evidence shows that once a teenager reaches the onset of puberty, the likelihood that they will eventually stop and identify with their birth gender is very low,” Strangio told the Court. In fact, according to more recent, better-designed studies, this percentage is approx one percent— or less.

But Cavanaugh wasn’t the only judge who seemed to believe that transgender teenagers should be saved from themselves. On several occasions, Justice Samuel Alito referred to recent guidelines from the Swedish government, as well as from the United Kingdom Cass Review. In both cases, health authorities found that the benefits of gender-affirming care had not been shown to outweigh its potential risks in all cases and set new limits on access.

However, as United States Solicitor General Elizabeth Preloger argued on behalf of the United States, neither Sweden nor the United Kingdom has completely banned gender-affirming care. Health officials in both countries recognize that gender-affirming care is necessary at least in some cases.

Cass Review was too largely criticized for selective use of data and bias in the database itself. It is worth noting that Dr Hilary Cass was chosen to lead the review because of her lack experience providing trans health care. And the original ‘terms of reference’ issued by the UK government intentionally excluded “Subject matter experts or people with lived experience of gender services” from the Assurance Team who guided the review process.

But even if the risks and regret rates were higher, would banning gender-affirming care really be good policy? According to many bioethicists, the answer is no.

This is due to a concept called the dignity of riskwhich arose out of the disability rights movement in the 1970s.

“Overprotection,” disability rights advocate Robert Perske wrote in a 1972 paper, undermines a person’s “individuality and potential for growth,” suffocates them emotionally, and prevents them “from experiencing the normal risk-taking in life necessary to normal human growth and development. .”

DT Photos1/Shutterstock

“There can be such a thing as human dignity at stake, and there can be a dehumanizing debasement in security,” Perske wrote.

Since the 1970s, researchers and ethicists have applied this framework to many other areas of medicine. In 2014, bioethicist Katie Watson wrote a comment at Journal of the American Medical Association implementation of the abortion framework.

Abortion and gender-affirming care are not the same thing—though abortion is it can be gender affirming care. What they have in common is that they are hated by the same people because they both allow people to cast aside rigid, traditional gender roles and take control of their sexuality and reproduction.

And let’s be extremely clear about one thing: It is very, very difficult to access gender-affirming care in the US requires tremendous determination and foresight. To suggest that young people who manage to overcome these barriers do so recklessly, or that providers and parents act recklessly in helping them, is offensive.

In another striking moment from last week’s arguments, Justice Amy Coney Barrett said she knew of no examples “de jure” discrimination against transgender people — in other words, government discrimination against transgender people, as a group, enacted in the form of laws, which is the type of discrimination at issue in this case.

Strangio pointed to, among other things, the US history of cross-dressing bans. These prohibitions date back in the mid-19th century, the same time that states also began to restrict abortion. The struggles for trans rights and reproductive rights in the US are and always have been.

And since its beginnings in the 19th century, the American anti-abortion movement has been a sophisticated disinformation machine. We now see the same people using the same playbook against trans people, and most despicably, against trans youth.

We see it in violence and threats of violence against care providers, a tactic long used by the anti-abortion movement to make the myth of “abortion is dangerous” true – not for the reasons the movement claims. We see this in the misleading and selective use of scientific evidence, or outright pseudoscience. We see this in the harsh and disparaging claims made about transgender people. We see it in the claim that bans like Tennessee’s are simply about protecting people, especially children.

Addressing misinformation requires the dissemination of corrective information everywhere. It also requires critical thinking. So let’s think critically about sadness.

Another commonality between abortion and gender-affirming care is low rates of regret. For example, the Turnaway study found that after five years, 95 percent of participants they still felt that abortion was the right choice for them.

And as a member of the Turnaway Study team Corinne Rocca he told me on my podcast, ACCESSin 2021, of those five percent who say they feel regret, 90 percent still feel that abortion was the right decision for them.

“I think it’s very important to distinguish the right decision or decision-making regret from having negative emotions or even the feeling of regret,” Rocca told me.

And even when people make choices they regret, isn’t that part of what makes us human?

Failure, Watson, the bioethicist, told me, “is part of being an autonomous adult. That’s how you learn. That’s how you develop resilience.”

In a 2022 paper, psychologists Wendy Heller and Haley Skymba he argued that the concept of the dignity of risk can also be applied to adolescent development. Not only is a certain amount of risk appropriate for the youth’s age, but it helps them develop good decision-making skills. Instead of trying to save teens from themselves, they argue, parents and guardians should help them make their own decisions and learn from them — even when they make mistakes.

Prices of regret for elective plastic surgery unrelated to gender-affirming care range as high as 47 percent. Almost 20 percent of people regret bariatric surgery. And about 10 percent of patients who regret having knee replacements. However, we do not limit these life-changing medical procedures based on high levels of regret and dissatisfaction—including young people. Why legislate based on risk fears and regrets about gender-affirming care, where those risks are objectively lower?

It’s about whether or not you see trans people as people—human beings who deserve dignity, the right to bodily autonomy, and the freedom to risk failure.

care dignity genderaffirming risk
bhanuprakash.cg
healthtost
  • Website

Related Posts

Erectile dysfunction in young men: causes and solutions

July 27, 2025

Trans Fighters are fighting to get discrimination in basic martial arts

July 26, 2025

3 Sti you can catch even if you are using a condom

July 25, 2025

Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Don't Miss
Skin Care

So easy Diy Eye Contouring Gel-The final anti-aging recipe!

By healthtostJuly 27, 20250

Sharing takes care of! Eye area is usually the first area to show age due…

Erectile dysfunction in young men: causes and solutions

July 27, 2025

Revealing the origin of autism, depression, Parkinson’s in the fetal brain

July 26, 2025

What is a light moisturizing and why do you need a

July 26, 2025
Stay In Touch
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • Vimeo
TAGS
Baby benefits body brain cancer care Day Diet disease exercise finds Fitness food Guide health healthy heart Improve Life Loss Men mental Natural Nutrition Patients Pregnancy protein research reveals Review risk routine sex sexual Skin study Therapy Tips Top Training Treatment ways weight women Workout
About Us
About Us

Welcome to HealthTost, your trusted source for breaking health news, expert insights, and wellness inspiration. At HealthTost, we are committed to delivering accurate, timely, and empowering information to help you make informed decisions about your health and well-being.

Latest Articles

So easy Diy Eye Contouring Gel-The final anti-aging recipe!

July 27, 2025

Erectile dysfunction in young men: causes and solutions

July 27, 2025

Revealing the origin of autism, depression, Parkinson’s in the fetal brain

July 26, 2025
New Comments
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Disclaimer
    © 2025 HealthTost. All Rights Reserved.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.